Universal resin cement: did you ever think about a third application mode?

Article by Prof. Lorenzo Breschi

Fewer bottles, more choices – this is possibly the shortest way to describe the category of universal resin cements. Being self-adhesive, these dual-cure resin-based cements allow for a single-component workflow without the need for separate tooth or restoration primers in many clinical situations. The bond strength obtained in this way is usually high enough to provide for a stable bond between the tooth and the restoration in a wide range of indications. However, it is slightly lower than that achieved with conventional resin cement systems consisting of several components (typically tooth primer, resin cement and restoration primer).

Apart from the self-adhesive application mode, universal resin cements may be combined with additional system components to increase the bond strength to tooth structure or the restorative material, respectively. This opens up new possibilities with regard to the product’s use: depending on the required or desired bonding performance, the universal resin cement may be applied alone or in combination with a tooth primer, a restoration primer or both components. In addition, hybrid concepts become feasible, as explained in this article that focuses on PANAVIA™ SA Cement Universal (Kuraray Noritake Dental Inc.) as an example.

Self-adhesive luting: for many indications

PANAVIA™ SA Cement Universal is a dual-cure universal resin cement that is indicated for a wide range of applications when used in the self-adhesive mode. The bond established to restorative substrates (including silicate ceramics) is high without the use of a separate primer or silane^1-4. This is due to two different adhesive monomers contained in the formulation – the Original MDP Monomer and the LCSi Monomer (a long carbon-chain silane coupling agent responsible for a strong chemical bond to silicate ceramics). Hence, it is possible to use the resin cement without any additional component applied on the side of the restoration – even in cases with a lack of retention and consequently high bond-strength requirements.

A strong bond to enamel and dentin is also obtained in the self-adhesive mode. In certain situations, however, it may be useful to further increase the bond strength to tooth structure with the aid of a tooth primer.

Adhesive luting: for challenging situations

The tooth primer recommended for PANAVIA™ SA Cement Universal is CLEARFIL™ Universal Bond Quick (Kuraray Noritake Dental Inc.). Its application is recommended whenever a user feels that the treatment would benefit from an extraordinarily strong and durable chemical bond, i.e. in particularly challenging situations with insufficient mechanical retention. The effectiveness of this measure has been confirmed in an in-vitro study conducted in Japan, in which the 24-hour micro-tensile bond strength to dentin was increased significantly by the application of the universal adhesive⁵. When a separate adhesive is used, however, the importance of a completely dry working field increases. The reason is that the moisture tolerance of resin cements is usually higher than that of adhesives. Consequently, the application of a rubber dam is highly recommended.

Selective adhesive luting: for short abutments and subgingival margins

For situations in which proper isolation of the working field with a rubber dam is difficult, a third application option is available and proposed by a group of Italian researchers: Selective Adhesive Luting. In this case, CLEARFIL™ Universal Bond Quick is applied solely to those parts of the prepared tooth that allow for proper moisture control, while relying on the self-adhesive functionality of PANAVIA™ SA Cement Universal in areas where it is challenging to obtain the desired dry working field. Situations which are predestined for this technique are abutment teeth with a subgingival preparation margin and particularly short abutment teeth (that hinder the placement of a rubber dam).

The effectiveness of the selective adhesive luting technique has been verified in an in-vitro study that compared the three adhesive strategies – self-adhesive luting, full adhesive luting and selective adhesive luting – with the aid of shear bond strength testing⁶. The results of the tests show that users are able to enhance the bond strength of PANAVIA™ SA Cement Universal to dentin and enamel by applying the adhesive to a part of the tooth surface only. For the cementation system consisting of PANAVIA™ SA Cement Universal and CLEARFIL™ Universal Bond Quick, the full adhesive and the selective adhesive approach led to similar outcomes.

For situations in which proper isolation of the working field with a rubber dam is difficult, a third application option is available and proposed by a group of Italian researchers: Selective Adhesive Luting.

RECOMMENDED STEPS FOR SELECTIVE ADHESIVE LUTING

Fig. 1. Tooth preparation.

Fig. 2. Selective etching of the enamel with phosphoric acid etchant.

Fig. 3. Application of the universal adhesive + air-drying.

Fig. 4. Crown placement after application of the resin cement into the crown.

Fig. 5. Tack-curing.

Fig. 6. Excess removal and final light curing.

Fig. 7. Treatment outcome at a recall after one year.

Benefits of selective adhesive luting

Apart from the desired (long-term) increase in bond strength achieved by applying a separate adhesive to a part of the or the whole prepared tooth surface, the technique offers additional benefits. Compared to multi-step cementation systems, the protocol is simplified as no separate restoration primer is needed. Light-curing of the adhesive is not required as long as the user stays within the recommended system. And in contrast to the full adhesive approach requiring rubber dam placement, the need for this step is eliminated in the selective adhesive approach. In this way, the chair-time is reduced and patient comfort increased.

Conclusion

Depending on the indication, clinical variables and individual preferences, users of universal resin cements like PANAVIA™ SA Cement Universal may select the technique that is likely to deliver the best clinical outcomes. It is this flexibility and the generally wide range of applications that makes the innovative product category truly universal. With fewer components to be used, universal materials facilitate the streamlining and standardization of clinical procedures, while with fewer bottles to be stored, they help staff gain control over order and storage management as well.

Dentist:

LORENZO BRESCHI

Prof. Lorenzo Breschi is Professor of Restorative Dentistry and Dental Materials at the University of Bologna. He is actively involved in research on the ultrastructural aspects of enamel and dentin. He is Past-President of the Academy of Dental Materials (ADM), President-Elect of the European Federation of Conservative Dentistry (EFCD), President-Elect of the Dental Materials Group IADR, President-Elect of the Italian Academy of Conservative Dentistry (AIC), President-Elect of the International Academy of Adhesive Dentistry (IAAD).

References

1. Cowen M, Cunha S, Powers JM. Novel Cement Bond Strength to Multiple Substrates. DENTAL ADVISOR Biomaterials Research Center, Biomaterials Research Report, Number 132 – June 16, 2020.
2. Patel N, Anadioti E, Conejo J, Ozer F, Mante F, Blatz M. Bond Strength of Different Self-Adhesive Resin Cements to Zirconia” (2021). Dental Theses. 62. https://repository.upenn.edu/dental_theses/62.
3. Yoshihara K, Nagaoka N, Maruo Y, Nishigawa G, Yoshida Y, Van Meerbeek B. Silane-coupling effect of a silane-containing self-adhesive composite cement. Dent Mater. 2020 Jul;36(7):914-926.
4. Irie M, Tokunaga E, Maruo Y, Nishigawa G, Yoshihara K, Nagaoka N, Minagi S, Matsumoto T. Shear bond strength of a resin cement to CAD/CAM Blocks for molars. P-2, 37th Annual Meeting of the Japanese Society of Adhesive Dentistry 2018.
5. Ohara N. Bonding strength of resin cement containing silane coupling agent to dentin or core resin. Results presented at the 150th meeting of the Japanese Society of Conservative Dentistry.
6. Breschi L, Josic U, Maravic T, et al. Selective adhesive luting: A novel technique for improving adhesion achieved by universal resin cements. J Esthet Restor Dent. 2023;1-9. doi:10.1111/jerd.13037.

• 2024. gada 7. maijs

PANAVIA SA Cement Universal Apskatīt produktu