KATANA™ Zirconia YML: Three experts classifying a new zirconia

One for all: With KATANA™ Zirconia YML (yttria multi-layered), Kuraray Noritake Dental Inc. has launched a true allrounder covering traditional and new zirconia indications. At the KATANA™ Zirconia YML Virtual Kick-Off Symposium on July 3, 2021, professionals from the clinical and technical field as well as scientific experts from Kuraray Noritake Inc. provided insights into the properties and benefits of the innovation. We had a conversation with three of them about the specific features of KATANA™ Zirconia YML and its potential role in the dental practice and laboratory. Mathias Fernandez Y Lombardi, EU Scientific Manager Dental Ceramics & CAD/CAM Materials, provided insights from inside the company, while Prof. Dr. Florian Beuer MME, Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin and MDT Nondas Vlachopoulos, owner of the dental laboratory AestheticLab in Athens, shared their external perspectives.

Prof. Dr. Florian Beuer MME and Mathias Fernandez Y Lombardi during the conversation at the Kick-Off Symposium in Munich.

MDT Nondas Vlachopoulos virtually attended the meeting.

What are the most important features and benefits of the new KATANA™ Zirconia YML?

Mathias Fernandez Y Lombardi: KATANA™ Zirconia YML is a 5^th generation zirconia featuring next-generation multi-layered technology: it offers colour, translucency and flexural strength gradation in one disc – for a virtually unlimited indication range. As it may be used as the only zirconia or even ceramic CAD/CAM material in a laboratory or milling centre, it is designed for everyone who would like to simplify and standardize laboratory procedures. It may be sintered within 54 minutes, offers a high accuracy of fit and may be finished using time-saving techniques.

The new discs presented at the KATANA™ Zirconia YML Virtual Kick-Off Symposium.

Multi-layered structure of KATANA™ Zirconia YML.

What are the benefits of using a single zirconia for every indication from the dental technician’s perspective?

Nondas Vlachopoulos: The use of a universal zirconia solution with a high aesthetic potential and well-aligned mechanical properties allows dental technicians to reduce their inventory and streamline their procedures – from designing to finishing. Nowadays, we all know that, in order to optimize the outcomes, it is essential that we develop a deep understanding of a material’s properties, respect its design parameters (like minimum wall thicknesses) and adhere to the sintering protocols. It is much easier to accomplish this for a single material than for many different ceramics, and the potential for errors is minimized with a single-material approach. With KATANA™ Zirconia YML, this approach enables us to produce very different outcomes depending on where the restoration is placed in the multi-layered blank.

What are the benefits of using KATANA™ Zirconia YML as the only ceramic material from the dental practitioner’s perspective?

Florian Beuer: To my mind, the most important benefit of using a single zirconia every time lies in a simplified documentation. When different ceramic materials are used in the dental laboratory, we need to keep track of the material selected in every single case. Only in this way, it is possible to make the right cementation decisions (regarding cement selection and the appropriate pre-treatment of the restoration). In addition, when it comes to failure of the restoration, we need to know which material was used to prove that it has been processed correctly and is suitable for the actual indication. This is much easier when a single material is used every time. Zirconia is predestined for this approach as it is forgiving, supports minimally invasive preparations and – in case of KATANA™ Zirconia YML – almost everything can be done with it.

What are the secrets of KATANA™ Zirconia YML that allow for excellent treatment outcomes despite the one-for-all approach?

Mathias Fernandez Y Lombardi: KATANA™ Zirconia YML is based on a completely new, seamless multi-layer technology combining different, newly developed raw materials with varying yttria concentrations in a single blank. The inhouse development of the powders and their precise adjustment of each other in terms of properties like shrinkage and coefficients of thermal expansion are prerequisites for a smooth transition from one layer to the next. Only if the layers are very well integrated, it will be possible to reliably produce even long-span restorations with a delicate design, perfect fit and flawless aesthetics (without transition lines). The aesthetic properties were also optimized by integrating clinical instead of purely technical translucency.

Please explain the term clinical translucency.

Mathias Fernandez Y Lombardi: Usually, translucency of dental materials like zirconia is measured in its white, pre-shaded state. This so-called technical translucency value is increased by adding yttria to the formulation, which makes the zirconia itself appear brighter (increasing the whiteness). The translucency of the final restoration, however, is also affected by pigments and other additives in the formulation. Consequently, monolithic restorations made of different materials with the same technical translucency value may vary widely in terms of their actual, clinical translucency, which affect the overall aesthetic potential. The formulation of KATANA™ Zirconia YML has been optimized by carefully selecting and combining the right additives to obtain a natural, tooth-like translucency.

Translucency and shade appearance of KATANA™ Zirconia YML (left column) compared to various other 5^th generation zirconia materials.

Nondas Vlachopoulos, is this measure of optimizing the clinical translucency a key feature enabling the one-for-all approach of KATANA™ Zirconia YML?

Nondas Vlachopoulos: The positive effect attributed to this measure is noticeable, as KATANA™ Zirconia YML has a particularly warm and natural appearance especially in the body area some other materials with flexural strength gradation are lacking. This leads to an exact colour match with the VITA classical A1-D4 shade guide, and reduces the need for manual shade adjustments. This is important for a one-for-all approach, as the material should be a perfect basis for the production of monolithic restorations, which are not covered by a thick porcelain layer able to mask any imperfections. However, there is another key feature that facilitates the zirconia’s use for virtually every indication: Its exceptional design flexibility. It enables users to control the translucency and overall aesthetics by positioning the restoration quite freely within the blank. For restorations with up to three units, there is a complete freedom of placement. Larger restorations with four or more units need to be positioned in a way that at least 50% of the connector cross-section is in the bottom half of the disc. This is easily accomplished and gives us optimal options to exploit the various properties of each layer depending on the aesthetics and strength needed in each specific case.

Positioning guidelines for KATANA™ Zirconia YML.

What is the recommended finishing procedure?

Mathias Fernandez Y Lombardi: In principle, all designs and finishing options are available for KATANA™ Zirconia YML – from a monolithic design individualized with liquid ceramics to microlayering after a minimal vestibular cutback or even full ceramic layering on frameworks. As the aesthetic potential of the zirconia is already high, however, we believe that in most cases, the first option is absolutely sufficient. In this case, a monolithic restoration is milled and the surface subsequently treated with our liquid ceramic system CERABIEN™ ZR FC Paste Stain. The pastes are easily applied in ultra-thin layers, very well controllable and wear resistant.

Anterior and posterior crown made of KATANA™ Zirconia YML after sintering (left part) and after sintering and finishing with CERABIEN™ ZR FC PASTE STAIN (right part).

Nondas Vlachopoulos, what is your preferred finishing procedure for restorations made of KATANA™ Zirconia YML?

Nondas Vlachopoulos: In the posterior area, I often opt for monolithic restorations individualized with CERABIEN™ ZR FC Paste Stain. The technique leads to beautiful outcomes a large majority of patients would love to see even in the anterior region. However, as orders for the production of anterior restorations coming my way are usually placed by clinicians and patients with the highest possible aesthetic demands, I often go for a framework design and full porcelain layering with CERABIEN ZR Porcelains. The materials (like EX-3 portfolio for metal frameworks) are based on synthetic feldspathic porcelain with a structure and particle distribution very similar to natural dentin and enamel. All in all, I like the fact that I can select the most suitable finishing technique for every individual case, and I believe that it is often possible to reduce the finishing effort to a minimum.

Clinical translucency, design flexibility, mechanical properties: Apparently, the differences between the available zirconia materials – even of the 5^th generation – are huge. How can users ensure that the material they select is of high quality and offers favourable mechanical as well as optical properties?

Florian Beuer: When the first-generation zirconia materials appeared on the dental market, laboratory testing revealed that there are huge differences in quality between materials of different manufacturers. Although independent studies comparing the properties and behaviour of 5^th generation zirconia are still scarce, it may be assumed that differences do exist. My recommendation is to select a several materials from well-known manufacturers supporting clinical studies, compare the study results already available, and test the selected options in the laboratory setting. Directly comparing design concepts, the processing quality and final appearance will most likely reveal which material is a dental technician’s favourite. I am sure that KATANA™ Zirconia YML is among the materials worth being tested.

Thank you for this insightful conversation.

• 2021-09-14

KATANA Zirconia YML View Product